When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. This doesn’t affect our editorial independence.
Italy sent major tax claims to U.S. technology firms Meta, X (formerly called Twitter), and LinkedIn on the grounds that the business model they employ—offering free access in exchange for user data—constitutes taxable transactions. The effort to place a financial value on personal data is a significant shift in the manner in which online services will be taxed within the European Union.
The Italian Revenue Agency is demanding an estimated €887.6 million from Meta, €12.5 million from X, and about €140 million from LinkedIn. The assessments are for the period 2015-2022 and differ with the company. The principal argument put forward by the Italian authorities is that when individuals register on such sites, they are effectively engaging in a barter deal—exchanging valuable information in return for access—making it subject to value-added tax (VAT).
The dispute is one of the most significant tax battles for the digital economy in the last few years, with repercussions extending beyond the boundaries of Italy. If the claim prevails, it will have the capacity to establish a precedent for EU nations and beyond and alter the tax treatment of multinational technology firms. Lawyers say other European tax authorities will likely take the same stance, leaving the door open to billions of euros in additional tax charges for digital platforms selling in the region.
Historically, digital platforms that operate under a data-for-service model have not been subject to VAT in this way. VAT is typically levied on monetary transactions, but Italian tax officials argue that user data has clear economic value and should be treated accordingly. If Italy’s tax authorities succeed, digital platforms may face obligations to pay VAT on the implied financial value of the user data they collect.
While not the first of its kind in Europe, the Italian effort is particularly aggressive. Previous tax fights in Europe have largely been about corporate tax—such as investigations into how large tech firms push profits to low-tax jurisdictions. The VAT situation goes in a different direction, targeting the very way that platforms generate revenue through the use of user data for targeted advertising and other commercial advantages.
The companies have 60 days to dispute the tax bills through an appeal or through a settlement with the government of Italy. Meta previously said it paid all tax laws applicable in the markets where it operates and will likely dispute the claims. X and LinkedIn have not responded specifically but state they abide by local tax laws.
Industry experts warn that if Italy’s approach gains traction, it could lead to broader tax changes in the EU, with other governments following suit. The European Commission has long sought to have the digital giants contribute additional tax revenues in the regions where they have a presence. The issue of taxing technology firms has been a contentious issue with the EU demanding a digital services tax where firms would be forced to contribute additional tax revenues in accordance with local economic activity.
The importance of the case goes far beyond short-term tax revenues. If it is successful, it would have the impact of revaluing personal information in financial and legal terms. Companies would need to rethink business models with the added possibility of including subscription fees or additional revenues to offset the VAT charge. Critics charge the action is politically motivated because European nations wish to exert greater financial control over Big Tech corporations. Others see it as a step toward modernising tax codes that have lagged the realities of the digital economy.
The case is in the infancy stage now and the final decision will take a few years to be realised with companies fighting the claims in courts. The signal from the governments in Italy is clear—governments now want to push the boundaries in the legal arena in the effort to tax internet giants. Tech firms will have to ready themselves for tax wars in the months and years to come with the pressure piling up in Europe.
